May 2024



X-Men: Dark Phoenix (2019)

DIRECTOR: Simon Kinberg

CAST: James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender, Sophie Turner, Nicholas Hoult, Tye Sheridan, Jennifer Lawrence, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Evan Peters, Alexandra Shipp, Jessica Chastain


For his directorial debut, screenwriter Simon Kinberg has fulfilled a long-harbored wish to take a second stab at the Dark Phoenix storyline he previously tackled as co-writer of 2006’s X-Men: The Last Stand, dissatisfied with the final product (which was directed by Brett Ratner). For fans of the X-Men comics, the Dark Phoenix storyline, written by Chris Claremont, John Byrne, and Dave Cockrum and running from the late 1970s into 1980, is regarded as one of the comics’ great narrative arcs (in addition to The Last Stand, it has also previously been adapted twice for animated television series). I’m not prepared to say a two hour movie has entirely done justice to a comic storyline which ran for years (reportedly Kinberg initially wanted to tell the storyline across two movies, but the studio declined), but comic book and film are different mediums. In its own right, Dark Phoenix has breathed a little more life into the loose reboot young X-Men series (began with 2011’s First Class and spun off into an alternate timeline by 2014’s Days of Future Past), more compelling than its immediate predecessor, the laborious Apocalypse and overall a better, if rushed and abridged, adaptation of the source material and the Dark Phoenix storyline than The Last Stand.

Continue reading

Logan (2017)

DIRECTOR: James Mangold

CAST: Hugh Jackman, Dafne Keen, Patrick Stewart, Boyd Holbrook, Stephen Merchant, Richard E. Grant, Eriq La Salle


Even more so than Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy, Logan defies the labels of “comic book” or “superhero” movie.  Together with last year’s Deadpoolit’s a rare “comic book movie” to earn a well-deserved R rating, but their tones couldn’t be more different.  Profanity and graphic violence flow freely in both, but while Deadpool was a tongue-in-cheek romp, Logan (loosely taking some elements from the Old Man Logan comic miniseries) is a dead serious, rather bleak affair.  But while their tones are polar opposites, Deadpool and Logan both refuse to play by conventional superhero movie rules.  Logan also serves as the swan song for two of moviedom’s most iconic superheroes, Hugh Jackman’s Wolverine and Patrick Stewart’s Charles Xavier (both of whom have reprised these characters off and on for the past seventeen years).  Small children should be left at home for this one, but for those to whom its grimness isn’t too jarring, Logan might be the most raw and uncompromising gut punch of any “comic book movie”.  Those who thought The Dark Knight was for grown-ups haven’t seen anything yet compared to where this movie dares to go. Continue reading

X-Men: Apocalypse (2016)

apocalypseDIRECTOR: Bryan Singer

CAST: James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender, Jennifer Lawrence, Nicholas Hoult, Rose Byrne, Oscar Isaac, Tye Sheridan, Sophie Turner, Kodi Smit-McPhee, Evan Peters, Lucas Till, Alexandra Shipp, Olivia Munn, Ben Hardy


X-Men: Apocalypse is the fourth comic book superhero movie to arrive in theaters in the first five months of 2016 (preceded by Deadpool, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justiceand Captain America: Civil War).  With so many comic book movies churning out left and right these days, over-saturation is a growing concern, and Apocalypse doesn’t do anything to distinguish itself in a crowded field.  In fact, it’s a disappointingly generic and muddled effort that, despite its attempts to up the ante, is a marked step down from its immediate predecessors X-Men: First Class and X-Men: Days of Future Past, nor is it as good as the original live-action X-Men movie or X2: X-Men United.  It’s better than the prequel misfire X-Men Origins: Wolverine (no great accomplishment) but stands about even with X-Men: The Last Stand (though, in fairness, despite its ominous title, Apocalypse doesn’t massacre half the cast, so while as muddled and uneven as Last Stand, it’s not as aggravating).  With Days of Future Past, returning series helmsman Bryan Singer (who directed and co-wrote 1 & 2) kept the fresh rejuvenating life Matthew Vaughn breathed into First Class going strong, but here, the rebooted series’ reclaimed energy and freshness is sputtering in fits and starts. Continue reading

X-Men: Days of Future Past (2014)

x-men-days-of-future-past-set-pic1DIRECTOR: Bryan Singer

CAST: Hugh Jackman, James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender, Jennifer Lawrence, Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellen, Nicholas Hoult, Peter Dinklage, Halle Berry, Ellen Page, Shawn Ashmore


Like some of the best comic book superhero movies (Nolan’s Batman trilogy, Captain America: The Winter Soldierand its own predecessor X-Men: First Class), X-Men: Days of Future Past, taking its name and some plot elements from a well-known X-Men comic storyline, mixes things up and takes the genre in unconventional directions.  The result is perhaps the strongest installment the X-Men film series has churned out yet, equaling or surpassing First Class.  Taking back his seat in the director’s chair from the likes of Gavin Hood and Matthew Vaughn, Bryan Singer has kept the fresh life First Class breathed into the floundering series going and taken it even further.  Days of Future Past, as its quirky title suggests, does something very different with the familiar characters, but as with its aforementioned cinematic cousins, different’s not a bad thing, especially when more generic comic book films are churning out left and right these days. Continue reading

X-Men: First Class (2011)

DIRECTOR: Matthew Vaughn


James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender, Jennifer Lawrence, Nicholas Hoult, Kevin Bacon, Rose Byrne, January Jones, Caleb Landry Jones, Lucas Till, Edi Gathegi, Zoe Kravitz, Jason Flemyng, Oliver Platt


Back when he wrote and directed 2000’s X-Men, Bryan Singer eschewed an origin story, jumping into the action with the X-Men already formed, deeming origin stories unnecessary and constraining.  A decade later, Singer (who helped develop the story and served as producer here) and director Matthew Vaughn decided to tackle the ‘origin story’ after all, not only of the ‘first class’ of X-Men, but the friends-turned-enemies Charles Xavier/Professor X and Erik Lensherr/Magneto.  While 2009’s X-Men Origins: Wolverine failed to do anything interesting with its central character, Vaughn and company have righted that wrong here.  First Class is easily ahead of The Last Stand, and might well top out X-Men and X2 for the best installment the series has produced so far. Continue reading

X-Men Origins: Wolverine (2009)

DIRECTOR: Gavin Hood


Hugh Jackman, Liev Schreiber, Danny Huston, Lynn Collins, Ryan Reynolds, Taylor Kitsch, Will.i.Am, Daniel Henney, Dominic Monaghan, Kevin Durand


Prequels rarely avoid feeling unnecessary, and X-Men Origins: Wolverine isn’t an exception. The spin-off for the character embodied onscreen in three X-Men films by Hugh Jackman (who produced here) is not exactly a train wreck, but it’s a bit of a disorganized mess that doesn’t escape a feeling of generic, uninspired redundancy. Continue reading

X-Men 3: The Last Stand (2006)

DIRECTOR: Brett Ratner


Hugh Jackman, Patrick Stewart, Sir Ian McKellen, Famke Janssen, Halle Berry, Kelsey Grammer, Anna Paquin, James Marsden, Shawn Ashmore, Aaron Stanford, Rebecca Romijn, Ellen Page, Ben Foster, Vinnie Jones, Josef Sommer, Bill Duke


X-Men 3: The Last Stand, the third installment of the original X-Men trilogy, is a mixed bag that veers from some of the best scenes in the series to a misjudged mess that desecrates some key characters and is crammed with more material than it can handle. Continue reading

X2: X-Men United (2003)

DIRECTOR: Bryan Singer


Hugh Jackman, Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellen, Anna Paquin, Famke Janssen, Halle Berry, James Marsden, Alan Cumming, Brian Cox, Rebecca Romijn, Bruce Davison, Kelly Hu, Shawn Ashmore, Aaron Stanford


With the success of 2000’s X-Men, director Bryan Singer and cast and crew were free in this sequel to move forward without the necessary exposition and character introduction which took a large chunk of the first film. The result supplies a faster pace and a little more ambition, along with an even heavier helping of the original’s underlying social commentary. Fans of the first should be pleased by the second. Continue reading

X-Men (2000)

DIRECTOR: Bryan Singer


Hugh Jackman, Patrick Stewart, Ian McKellen, Anna Paquin, Halle Berry, Famke Janssen, James Marsden, Bruce Davison, Ray Park, Rebecca Romijn, Tyler Mane


Since the X-Men comic book series was first introduced in the 1960s, it has been one of Marvel Comics’ most consistently popular titles. It had already been an animated television series, and it was inevitable that it would be made into a feature film sooner or later. Now that it has been done, its loyal fans are probably a little divided over it. Some will appreciate writer-director Bryan Singer’s faithfulness to the source material and his serious effort to transfer it from page to screen as intact as possible. But with any large following, it is impossible to please everyone, with the most minor alterations leaving some outraged. Personally, as someone who collected X-Men comics when younger, I approve of Singer’s respect for the mythos and characters, but it’s been too long since I’ve read the comics to even know most of what was changed or left out, and in any case it doesn’t bother me. A comic book series which carries on for decades and thus can include endless complex interweaving plotlines and a vast array of characters and a two-hour movie are different mediums. Singer keeps things simple and straightforward; one doesn’t need familiarity with the source material to understand and enjoy the film. X-Men is essentially comic book action-adventure fantasy escapism, but an embedded social message about overcoming fear and hatred lends it a touch of depth beyond just a summer action flick.

The premise is that mankind has begun evolving into mutants with superhuman powers which cannot be explained or understood by the average person, and as such are largely feared and even hated. And among the mutants, battle lines have been drawn between two ideologically opposed groups. One is led by the psychic Professor Charles Xavier (the commanding Patrick Stewart, who even looks like the comic book character), who runs a school for ‘gifted students’ in New York, actually a place where mutant children can come and be taught to hone their powers in an accepting and encouraging environment. Xavier has hopes that mankind will come to accept mutants in time, and also uses the school as a cover for the secret base where he and his team of likeminded mutants try to counter the other, less benevolent group led by Xavier’s old friend Erik Lensherr/Magneto (Sir Ian McKellen). Embittered by his childhood experiences in Nazi concentration camps, Erik/Magneto has no faith in humanity and has come to view himself as superior to them. His disgust for mankind’s bigotry is only reinforced by the McCarthy-esque Senator Kelley (Bruce Davison), who incites fear of mutants and is pushing discriminatory legislation. Xavier’s team is made up of the telepathic Jean Grey (Famke Janssen), Cyclops (James Marsden), who shoots laser blasts from his eyes, and weather-controlling Storm (Halle Berry in a white wig). Newcomers to the group are Rogue (Anna Paquin), who drains the life force—and absorbs the powers—of anyone she touches with her bare skin, and the mysterious Wolverine (buffed-up Aussie newcomer Hugh Jackman, whose accent slips once or twice). Wolverine gets the most screentime of anyone, and has the most shadowy back-story; obviously the victim of extensive and horrific experimentation, he has had an indestructible metal grafted onto his entire skeleton, giving him the ability to grow metal spikes out of his hands. Magneto’s group includes the shape-shifting Mystique (an unrecognizable Rebecca Romijn), Toad (Ray Park, best-known as Darth Maul in Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace) who has a nasty way with his tongue, and the hulking Sabertooth (professional wrestler Tyler Mane)…and they’re up to something. The loner Wolverine and the teenage runaway Rogue must decide whether to embrace Xavier’s offer of help—and his cause—or continue on their own.

X-Men should please most fans by showing off each character’s powers, but has received some criticism for focusing more on Wolverine, Magneto, and Rogue than anyone else. That may be a legitimate criticism (although the above three are also for my money the most three-dimensional and compelling characters), but it already has a large cast of characters and focusing on all of them equally would bog the movie down. As it is, it already spends almost half its running time on exposition and character introduction and development, which for the introductory outing may have been a necessary evil. With special effects-heavy action sequences and an undercurrent of humor, it is likely to entertain most theatergoers, and keeps the characters, their powers, and the plot easy to keep track of.   X-Men’s tone, while occasionally hitting a surprisingly poignant moment, is fairly lightweight, and it focuses more on the origin aspect than the plot, which leads to an action-packed climax but keeps fairly modest goals. X-Men doesn’t aspire for the epic, and it lacks the ambition and scope of Superman, but it’s entertaining and fulfills what it sets out to accomplish. All of the actors do well enough in their roles, especially Ian McKellen, Hugh Jackman, Anna Paquin, and Patrick Stewart, but the others are not given too much to do.

A few qualities raise X-Men above mere comic book escapism. One is the casting of Patrick Stewart and Ian McKellen, whose commanding and dignified presences bring a touch of class and grant the movie a little needed gravitas. Another, probably most significantly, is the underlying theme of tolerance and accepting differences which runs throughout the movie, never too overt or preachy to interfere with the action sequences and special effects, but never far under the surface either. The big brother-little sister type bond between the gruff but ultimately humane Wolverine and the lonely and alienated Rogue has a touch of depth, and Anna Paquin effectively projects the pain and loneliness of being cast out from society for being different.  Hugh Jackman, an Aussie unknown in the States, is likely to launch himself into budding heartthrob status and embodies some trademarks of the comic character (he chomps on cigars and says “bub”).  Jackman has the charisma to be as close to a main “star” as we have, though he’s also given the most central attention.  Thus, while X-Men can simply be enjoyed for the action-adventure escapism it is, it, like the comic series, is fundamentally an allegory for the struggles of minorities facing discrimination and hatred, and the symbolism, both on the page and the screen, isn’t hard to see. Also adding complexity is the fact that while Magneto’s plan might be a little silly (it involves building a machine to transform all the world leaders gathered for a summit on Ellis Island into mutants) Magneto himself is not quite your standard issue comic book megalomaniac. He is a bitter and cynical man who has lived through the horrifying levels intolerance can reach and is resorting to extreme measures to protect himself and his people, and McKellen and the filmmakers portray Magneto as more misguided than evil, and more three-dimensional than the villains we typically expect to see in comic book movies.

X-Men’s maintaining of the comics’ emphasis on the plight of minorities is unsurprising considering that its young writer-director, Bryan Singer, who made a name for himself with 1995’s The Usual Suspects, is both Jewish and gay (Singer also directed the far darker and disturbing Apt Pupil, which also featured Ian McKellen and Bruce Davison). Both Singer and the also openly gay Sir Ian McKellen have commented in interviews that the mutants’ struggle for acceptance striking a chord with their own backgrounds was what attracted them to the film. If embedding a message of tolerance inside an action-packed summer flick will get more people to hear it, so be it, although many will likely only be dazzled by the special effects and action scenes and not read between the lines to get the underlying point. In any case, whether you see it as a call for tolerance or entertainment or both, X-Men serves as solid escapist fantasy with an underlying message of acceptance and understanding that’s as relevant today as ever.